How to Cook a New York Strip Steak

September 4, 2024 By Snake River Farms

How to Cook a New York Strip Steak

Embark on a culinary journey with our How to Cook Guide for American Wagyu New York strip steaks. Hand-cut for natural size variation, these thick strips offer the amazing flavor and tight texture of a perfect New York strip steak. As you dive into the art of cooking, discover the unique characteristics of American Wagyu beef – deeply marbled with a wonderful complexity and subtle sweetness. Elevate your cooking skills and savor an unparalleled steak experience with our comprehensive guide.

5 Ways to Cook New York Strip Steak

Five foolproof methods to master the perfect New York Strip steak at home

1. Steak House Method

How to cook New York Strip steak in the oven:

Season - Heat a heavy skillet over medium-high heat until hot. Add a light coat of vegetable oil to the skillet. Season strip steaks with salt and pepper.
Sear - Place steaks in hot skillet and sear for 4 minutes, turning once. If a steak sticks to the skillet, it’s not ready to turn. Wait until it releases on its own.
Cook - Place skillet in a 350°F degree oven for 10 to 20 minutes depending on desired doneness. Turn once halfway through the cooking time. Remove from oven when preferred internal temperature is reached. See chart below for suggested temperatures.
Rest - Remove steaks from a skillet and cover loosely with aluminum foil. Let stand 5 to 10 minutes. The steaks will continue to cook and the temperature will rise about 5 degrees.

2. Pan Searing

How to cook the New York Strip steak on the stovetop:

Season - Heat a heavy skillet (cast iron is ideal) over medium heat until hot. Add a light coat of vegetable oil to the skillet. Season top side of New York Strip steaks with salt and pepper.
Sear - Place strip steaks, seasoned side down, in skillet and sear 4 to 5 minutes until nicely browned. Season the top side of the steak with salt and pepper. If the steak sticks to the skillet, it’s not ready to turn. Wait until it releases on its own.
Flip - Turn steaks over and allow to cook for an additional 3 to 5 minutes. After 2 to 3 minutes, use a thermometer to test the thickest part of the steak. When the temperature reaches the desired level, remove from the skillet. See chart below for temperature guidelines. Remove steaks from a skillet and serve.
Rest - Remove steaks from a skillet and cover loosely with aluminum foil. Let stand 5 to 10 minutes. The steaks will continue to cook and the temperature will rise about 5 degrees.

3. Reverse Sear

How to reverse sear a New York Strip steak:

Season - Heat oven to 275°F degrees. Season strip steak with salt and pepper. Cover a baking sheet with foil and place a metal rack in the middle. The idea is to elevate the steak from the pan.
Cook - Place the pan, grill and New York Strip in the oven. Bake until the steak reaches the temperature that matches your preference. See the chart for exact temperatures. For medium-rare, cook until 120°F degrees. This can take up to 60 minutes, but begin checking the internal temperature at 30 minutes. See chart below for temperature guidelines.
Rest - Remove steak from oven, loosely cover with foil and allow to rest for 10 to 15 minutes.
Sear - Add a light coating of vegetable oil to a heavy skillet and heat over high heat until hot. Sear New York Strip on each side for 60 to 90 seconds to form a beautiful crust. Serve.

4. Grilling

How to grill New York Strip steak:

Season - Turn on grill to medium heat. Season grill with a light coat of vegetable oil. Season strip steaks with salt and pepper or your favorite rub. rub.
Sear - Place steak on hot grill, close lid and allow to cook for 2 minutes. Lift steak off the grill, turn 45 degrees and place back on the grill. Allow to cook 2 more minutes.
Flip - Turn steak over and cook for 2 minutes. Lift steak off the grill, turn 45 degrees and place back on the grill. Allow to cook for 2 more minutes. For medium-rare, the total cook time is 8 minutes. Check the temperature of the thickest part of the steak to determine when it is done to your preference. See chart below for temperature guidelines.
Rest - Remove steaks from the skillet and cover loosely with aluminum foil. Let stand 5 minutes. The steaks continue to cook the temperature will rise about 5 degrees. Finish with a pinch of flaked salt. Serve.

4. Sous Vide

How to sous vide a New York Strip steak:

Heat Water - Place your immersion circulator in a container with water and set the temperature. See the chart below to determine the best temperature to achieve the result you desire. See the chart to determine the best temperature to achieve the result you desire.
Season - Use a generous amount of salt and pepper on both sides of the New York Strip steak.
Package & Seal - Use a vacuum sealer to seal the steak in a bag. You can also use a self-sealing plastic bag by placing the bag in a container of water, being careful to keep the lid above the waterline. The water pressure will displace the air as the steak drops deeper into the water. Seal the bag when all or most of the air has been pushed out of the bag.
Cook - Place the sealed bag into the water. We recommend cooking your steak a minimum of one hour and no longer than two hours.
Heat Skillet - Add a light coat of vegetable oil to a heavy skillet. Place on a burner set to medium-high heat.
Sear - Remove the steak from the sealed bag. Pat the steak dry and place in the hot pan. Cook about 1 to 2 minutes per side to create a brown, crisp crust. Steaks cooked sous vide do not require resting so you can serve immediately.

Steak Temperature Guide

Here are the magic numbers you’ll need to determine when your New York Strip steak is cooked to the degree of doneness you most prefer. The internal temp is when the New York Strip Steak should be removed from the heat. The steak will continue to cook, so the temperature will rise during the rest period.